Blog

Where do I submit? How scientific journals report analytics

In this blog, Lily will take you through the ins and outs of some common journal metrics, impact factor, citescore, eigenfactor and altmetrics to help you find the best fit for your (or your client’s) manuscript.

RD Journal WB

Journal level analytics

Impact factor

Impact factor is the most well-known of all the journal metrics. It is calculated in quite a simple way and, as such, does not have the nuance of some of the others measures.

How is impact factor calculated?

Impact factor is calculated using the number of citations the journal has. That is the number of times published papers in other journals have referenced papers from that journal using the Clarivate Journal Citation Reports (JCR) database. The total number of citations in the current year divided by the total number of published papers in the 2 years prior (original research and reviews).

Metrics IF

How is impact factor used?

Impact factor gives you an overview of how influential a journal is. For example, at the time of writing The New England Journal of Medicine, one of the most notable journals in the world, has an impact factor of 84.5. For context, this means that each paper published in The New England Journal of Medicine in 2 years was cited an average of 84.5 times in the present year. Although you need a paid membership to access the calculation data, search the JCR database and search for impact factors on the official Clarivate website, you can usually find a journal’s impact factor on their webpage in the ‘metrics’ section. Journals themselves buy the licence for the impact factor in order to publish it online. Because impact factor is the ‘original recipe’ analytic, most academics are familiar with it and it is therefore still frequently used as standard.

Citescore

Citescore is another common journal metric you’ll see in journals’ ‘about us’ sections. It is similar to impact factor in in the way that it’s calculated. However, it differs slightly in the timeframe that is used and the database it gathers its information from.

How is Citescore calculated?

The total citations from papers published in the preceding 4 years are used, rather than 2, and are divided by the number of citable papers published in those 4 years. This metric also pulls from the Scopus abstract and citation database, rather than JCR.

Metrics CS

How is Citescore used?

The longer window is one reason that Citescore might be more appealing than impact factor with journals on topics that are less cited (like the social sciences or engineering). Other reasons include that Citescore works from a different, broader database from impact factor. The Scopus database counts all papers, not just original research and reviews, and is free for journals to use (unlike impact factor). For this reason, if you are publishing in a field that has a slower citation rate, Citescore might be the best option to understand a journal’s true impact. In biomedical fields, where citations occur frequently, the measures are likely broadly comparable.

Eigenfactor

The Eigenfactor is a more dynamic approach to determining influence. It places a higher value on citations from more reputable journals, meaning that the score may be more reflective of the importance a journal has in the scientific community.

How is Eigenfactor calculated?

Eigenfactor is calculated over five years and combines citation score and article influence. The calculations for article influence work in a similar to the way the Google ranks and returns your search results. The Eigenfactor uses computational systems and algorithms to rank articles by their importance and adjusts for the discrepancies in how different disciplines are cited. For example, in their methodology, they explain that a report in a leading cell biology journal might receive 10-30 citations within two years; the average article in leading mathematics journal would do very well to receive 2 citations over the same period. The algorithms adjust for this for a fairer overview of the analytics.

Metrics EF

How is Eigenfactor used?

Eigenfactor is free to use and search and is designed to be used by researchers, academic librarians and anyone else who has an interest in understanding journal performance. The score should be interpreted as the journal’s total importance in the scientific community. It is scaled as a percentage of all journals that appear in the JCR database. So, a journal with an Eigenfactor score of 1 holds 1% of the total influence of all the journals in that database. For reference, 1 is a great score, in 2025, Nature had an Eigenfactor score of 0.98.

What next? Publication level altmetrics

Altmetrics, or alternative metrics, are the new kid on the block in the analytics world. When searching for papers you may have seen this colourful doughnut next to the report you’re reading. This is provided by Altmetric.com which is one of the companies that provides information about altmetrics. Altmetric is used by Nature, other types of alternative metrics include PlumX metrics, which is used by The Lancet.

Metrics AM

Altmetrics do not measure the journal but rather provide important information about the reach of a specific paper that goes beyond journal citations. social media attention on sites like X, Reddit and YouTube and where the paper is mentioned on Podcasts, news articles or is cited in Wikipedia. Attention comes in the form of mentions of the paper by its title or content or its DOI or other identifier in comments, posts, shares etc.

In the case of Altemetric, these mentions and citations are combined into an ‘attention score’. This score is weighted as mentions in some sources such as newspapers will likely extend the reach of the paper more than a mention in a social media post. The weighting of each mention is determined using a dynamic automated algorithm that considers the type, the source and the author of the mention. The sum of the attention score from all the mentions is the number given in the characteristic Almetric Doughnut which links to a details page where you can look through the original mentions that make up the score. Remember, not all press is good press, so a high attention score doesn’t necessarily mean the attention is positive!

PlumX metric, on the other hand, will give you an overview of the captures and mentions. It doesn’t create an overall ‘score’ but breaks down the data into five categories: Citations, usage, captures, mentions and social media. Citations and social media are as you would expect, citations and social media likes and shares. Usage aims to measure if the research is being used, it includes downloads, clicks and views of the abstract or paper. Captures are indicators that people want to come back to the report to use or cite it later, they are counted when people bookmark it on their browser, add it to Mendeley and other readers etc. Mentions are a measurement of engagement with the research and include blog posts, news articles and Wikipedia pages that reference the report in some way.

If you are a publications medical writer, I suggest going back to a published manuscript you have worked on and looking at who is talking about it. Maybe it’s been mentioned in some interesting corners of the internet!

Overall, there are some useful ways to measure journal performance in the academic world. The metrics mentioned here are just a sampling of some of the most commonly used. Though this information can help you decide what journal might be a good fit for your research or manuscript, the best way to know is always going to be delving in and having a read. It is also always important to keep an open – but critical – mind, and not discount research that might be published in a lesser-known journal. In addition, it’s wise not to put too much weight on those published in the big-name journals, just because of the name recognition, prestige doesn’t automatically equal scientific rigor.

Keen to start your publications journey, you can buy our pubs toolkit here: https://development.rubyduke.co.uk/publications-toolkit

Share this page